phillypressbox

Posts Tagged ‘Joe Paterno’

“UPLIFTING ATHLETES” – The Charity for Rare Diseases

In College Football, Penn State Football on February 8, 2014 at 8:17 pm

Uplifting Athletes

In July 2013, as a result of a routine physical, it was determined that I had a 1″ cancerous tumor on my left kidney. Two weeks later, August 13, I had surgery to remove the tumor. When I woke up I learned that they had to remove my entire left kidney, my adrenal gland, my lymph node and a part of a rib. The tumor was imbedded and the cancer had started to spread. I had a 7″ incision being held together by 16 staples. Like any other person that has ever been told they have cancer it scares you to death. I started researching and reading everything I could about it. I learned that kidney cancer is considered a “rare disease”because it affects fewer than 200,000 Americans. As a result, there’s little funding for research and few options for treatment. It also doesn’t respond to chemotherapy and radiation so your choices are simple, you remove it or you don’t and take the chance it doesn’t spread.

During my research I came across and article about a man named Don Shirley. Mr. Shirley’s life activities mirrored mine in many ways. He was a high school coach, as was I. He had no symptoms or family history of cancer, nor did I. Mr Shirley first encountered kidney cancer in 1993 before finally passing away when the cancer came back in 2005, at the age of 55, I would turn 55, one month after my surgery. I also learned that Mr. Shirley had a son, Scott, that was a member of my favorite college football team, the Penn State Nittany Lions. He had graduated in December 2004 from Penn State with a master’s degree in engineering. I had coached at the Penn State Summer Football Camps for 12 summers and was a season ticket holder. I found the story of Scott Shirley very interesting as well and needed to know more about him and the charity that he started called “Uplifting Athletes” that raises money for nearly 7000 rare diseases.

I found contact information and reached out to Scott We’ve talked several times and communicate regularly through social media. the more we talked the more intrigued I became and the more I wanted to share his story. We recently sat down and did a question and answer session.

PHILLY PRESSBOX (PP): Can you tell us about yourself and your background?
SCOTT SHIRLEY (SS):
I am a husband and father who helps college football student-athletes learn how to leverage the position they are in to help other by using their natural talents to the best of their ability. During my time at Penn State I was a wide receiver on the football team (1999-2003) and a catcher on the baseball team (2001). The degrees that I’ve earned include a BS in Engineering and Masters of Engineering from Penn State and I am an Executive Scholar from Northwestern’s Kellogg School of Management. Currently I serve as the Executive Director of Uplifting Athletes Inc and CEO of PledgePlatform LLC. Community involvement includes the Board of Directors for AmeriChoice Federal Credit Union and the Board of Governors for the Maxwell Football Club. In my free time I play semi-pro baseball for the Mechanicsburg Cardinals.

PP: How did Uplifting Athletes come about?
SS: Our effort started in 2003 when my father was diagnosed with kidney cancer and my family learned that little could be done because it was a rare disease – meaning it affected fewer than 200,000 Americans and lacked financial incentive to make and market new treatments. When my teammate/roommate Damone Jones (OL from Philadephia, PA) learned of our misfortune, he suggested that we do something since we were in a position to make a difference. Our team rallied around the idea of leveraging a summer strength and conditioning competition into a fund raising event called Lift For Life® by opening it up to our fans and the media. We soon realized that the benefits of this new organization were far greater than we had imagined.
The football student-athletes who were involved with leading this effort essentially created internship experiences for ourselves by reaching out to industry professional mentors. The benefits of off campus summer internships are well documented but are often void from the college experience of football student-athletes due to our year round commitment to the sport. We also realized that our teammates were actively engaged because this was something the team had ownership over, not a community service project that was planned by someone else. Finally, we learned that kidney cancer was one of more than 7,000 rare diseases (such as cystic fibrosis, Hodgkins disease or charcot-marie-tooth disease), affecting more than 30-million Americans and that we were making a big difference.
Since 2003, the Penn State Football chapter has raised more than $800,000 to benefit kidney cancer; its events have attracted thousands of fans and media and connected patients from across the country. Eight new treatments have been brought to market during this time, compared with only one in the previous 12 years. We have inspired 20 other teams to start chapters of Uplifting Athletes, too, creating a coordinated effort to elevate the rare disease cause.

PP: What is the mission of Uplifting Athletes?
SS: Our mission is to align college football with rare diseases and raise them as a national priority through advocacy, education, outreach and research. Our vision is to create an environment that empowers people to take action against rare diseases and inspires the medical community to find cures.

PP: How many football programs are presently involved?
SS: Our network of chapters includes more than 20 college football teams representing every major conference including half of the B1G Ten and ACC. Each chapter is run by current football student-athletes and adopts a rare disease that’s had an impact on their team. Collectively we have raised more $2MM to support rare disease research and have created special moments like “Jack’s Run” at Nebraska (the 7-year-old pediatric brain cancer patient who scored a 69-yard touchdown during their spring game). See the video clip below. Over the past six years we’ve graduated more than 200 Uplifting Athletes “Lettermen.” Their professions range from the NFL to Wall Street.

PP: You played for Coach Paterno at Penn State, would you care to comment on him, what happened to his legacy and his importance to you as a former PSU student athlete?
SS: Coach Paterno’s legacy is his former players. Our actions will continue to shape the memory of him and expand the impact that he had. Time and patience will heal the wounds from the Sandusky scandal.
Coach Paterno built a program on values that brought me and my friends together to serve as the catalyst, Uplifting Athletes.

PP: How can a person help that may just want to donate to this cause?
SS: Donations can be made through our website at http://www.upliftingathletes.org and directed towards a chapter/rare disease or you can make a general donation towards our mission.

PP: Do you have any events or recognitions now that the college football season is over?

SS: Our annual Gridiron Gala (www.upliftingathletes.org/gridirongala) is coming up on Saturday, March 8th. Tickets are available and it is open to the public. It is expected to be an outstanding event!!
Also, we recently conducted an online vote for the 2014 Rare Disease Champion. We are proud to recognize Nebraska’s C.J. Zimmerer. The trophy will be presented at the Maxwell Football Club’s annual award dinner.

The more I thought about Uplifting Athletes and how they operate the more impressed I became. Student athletes passing the torch from class-to-class and growing the chapters. How cool is that to be able to leave your legacy at your college by being the chairman for the year of such a beneficial fundraiser?

In closing, Scott Shirley has committed his life to making a difference through Uplifting Athletes. We commend him for his efforts in starting and growing such a great cause.

You to can make a difference by educating yourself about rare diseases and, if you are able, donating to the cause at http://www.upliftingathletes.org.

Advertisements

Philly Pressbox Trivia – PENN STATE FOOTBALL

In Penn State Football on January 31, 2014 at 6:27 am

th4

This question has several answers. December 30, 1967 marks the first bowl game under Joe Paterno, the Gator Bowl. One player passed for both touchdowns, kicked both extra points and kicked a field goal but only passed for 69 yards. Can you name him? As a bonus, who did the Nittany Lions play and what was the final score?

Philly Pressbox is proud of our association with the Kisses for Kyle Foundation. Please check out their link at http://www.shop.com/kissesforkyle  Every purchase you make helps families battling childhood cancer in the Delaware Valley.

Kisses for Kyle

The Demise of the Paterno Legacy, the Freeh Report

In Joe Paterno, Penn State Football on July 29, 2012 at 6:22 pm

Anyone that follows Philly Pressbox knows that I’m a huge Penn State fan and a huge Joe Paterno fan. You also know that I’ve been a season ticket holder and I coached at the Penn State Football camps from 1994-2002.  I had the opportunity to meet Joe Paterno several times and have a signed picture with him hanging on my wall. I also worked with Jerry Sandusky during those years until his retirement, as well as the rest of the coaching staff. I knew Sandusky by name and he knew me by name during that time. With that said, this chain of events saddens me to no end. Obviously, the most important thing in this tragedy is the victims. Anything that is noted in this article is not meant to diminish them and what they have had to endure in any way. Please keep that as the top note.

As I watched the craziness of seeing Paterno fired by what appeared to be a disorganized, panic stricken, Board of Trustees that appeared to be bowing to the media and public pressure to do “something” even if it was wrong, I was filled with disbelief. Seeing Joe Paterno die so quickly amidst all of this without ever seeing the end of it was also saddening. Watching the Sandusky trial and the verdicts I couldn’t help but be sickened and wonder how could this happen. I then listened to the Louis Freeh press conference and the presentation of the Freeh Report and was in disbelief, and again wondered how could this possibly happen. Finally, the word came that the Paterno statue was being removed on a Sunday morning under the cover of darkness and secrecy. With that, I decided I needed to read the Freeh Report for myself and see what exactly was so damning to a man that built Penn State University, and the local community, over 62 years as the football coach, into one of the finest institutions in America that is filled with over 500,000 living alumni, pride and key slogans. (Success with Honor, We are Penn State).

The purpose of my reading the Freeh Report was to look strictly at the actions, or inactions, of Joe Paterno to try to determine for myself where I feel he stands in this tragedy. My finding is that there are many things in this report that a purely speculative and made from assumptions. There is some very good information here that can, and apparently will, be used by the university to improve awareness of signs of child abuse and provide training for all employees regarding the Clery Act among many other things as well as implement a system that guarantees communication at the highest levels to the Board of Trustees among many other things.  However, as I will point out below, how can a report be “the gospel” by the university and the NCAA when none of the “key” players were interviewed for the report? They include Joe Paterno, Graham Spanier, Tim Curley, Gary Schultz, Mike McQueary, Jerry Sandusky, Wendell Courtney, and Thomas Harmon. Richard “Dick” Anderson is the only assistant coach mentioned in the report and that is in relation to his Grand Jury testimony representing Sandusky, although it is stated that they talked to many people “including coaches”. So who are Wendell Courtney and Thomas Harmon, you ask? Courtney served as Penn State’s Outside Legal Counsel from 1980-2010 and was a partner at a law firm that performed legal services for the University for nearly 50 years. Courtney also served as legal counsel for the Second Mile and sat on its Board from 2008-2011. (page 107). Harmon is currently the Penn State Director of Public Safety. He held the position of University Department Police Chief in 1998. It’s very interesting that they wouldn’t be included in the report as they were key pieces to this story. Also, have you ever heard of the following people; Alycia Chambers, Ron Schreffler, Chambers colleagues, John Miller, Jerry Lauro, Karen Arnold, John Seasock as well as several State College Police Officers? Each was involved in the in-depth 1998 Sandusky investigation in which no charges were filed because, as it states on page 50, “there was no criminal behavior established (and) that the matter was closed as an investigation.”

Alycia Chambers – a licensed State College psychologist. She was the first person notified by Victim 6’s mother. Page 42.

Ron Schreffler – University Police Department Detective that conducted the initial interviews with Victim 6. Page 42.

Chambers Colleagues – undetermined number of people that Chambers consulted with to confirm her opinion. Page 42

John Miller – Caseworker with the Centre County Children and Youth Services (“CYS”). Page 43.

Jerry Lauro – Caseworker with the Department of Public Welfare (DPW) in Harrisburg. Page 43.

Karen Arnold – Centre County Prosecutor in the District Attorney’s office. Page 43.

John Seasock – Contract counselor to CYS. Page 43.

State College Police Officers – unnamed officers that hid in Victim 6’s home when Sandusky admitted to poor behavior but no sexual contact with Victim 6. Page 45.

For the purpose of this review lets assume that Chambers had two colleagues and there were two State College Police Officers listening in on the conversation with Victim 6’s mother. That makes 12 trained professionals in this type of behavior that were aware of this situation. Yet, in the end of the investigation no charges were filed.

On to the document. Following is the Table of Contents:

  • ·        Pages I – VII – Title Page and Table of Contents
  • ·        Pages 8- 10 – Scope of Review and Methodology
  • ·        Pages 11-12 – Independence of the Investigation
  • ·        Pages 19-30 – Timeline of Significant Events
  • ·        Pages 31- 38 – Chapter 1: The Pennsylvania State University – Governance and Administration
  • ·        Pages 39-54 – Chapter 2: Response of University Officials to the Allegations of Child Sexual Abuse Against Sandusky – 1998
  • ·        Pages 55-61 – Chapter 3: Sandusky’s Retirement from the University – 1999
  • ·        Pages 62-79 – Chapter 4: Response of University Officials to the Allegations of Child Sexual Abuse Against Sandusky – 2002
  • ·        Pages 80-96 – Chapter 5: Response of University Officials to the Grand Jury Investigation – 2010, 2011
  • ·        Pages 97-102 – Chapter 6: Board of Trustees
  • ·        Pages 103-109 – Chapter 7: Sandusky’s Post Retirement Interactions with the University
  • ·        Pages 110-119 – Chapter 8: Federal and State Child Sexual Abuse Reporting Requirements
  • ·        Pages 120-126 – Chapter 9: The Protection of Children in University Facilities and Programs
  • ·        Pages 127-144 – Chapter 10: Recommendations for University Governance, Administration and the Protection of Children in University Facilities and Programs
  • ·        Pages 145- End – Appendices

On page 11 of the report it states, The Special Investigative Council discovered the most important documents in this investigation – emails among former President Graham B. Spanier, former Senior Vice President-Finance and Business Gary C. Shultz and Athletic Director Timothy M. Curley from 1998 and 2001 – relating to Sandusky’s crimes.” There is no mention of any emails from Paterno.

  • ·        Pages 13-18 – Executive Summary

 

Page 14 of this chapter, under the section “Findings” is the first mention of Paterno in this report. The report states, “Four of the most powerful people at the Pennsylvania State University – President Graham B. Spanier, former Senior Vice President-Finance and Business Gary C. Shultz and Athletic Director Timothy M. Curley and Head Football Coach Joseph V. Paterno – failed to protect against a child predator harming children for over a decade. These men concealed Sandusky’s activities from the Board of Trustees, the university community and authorities. They exhibited a striking lack of empathy for Sandusky’s victims by failing to inquire as to their safety and well being, especially by not attempting to determine the identity of the child in the Lasch building in 2001. Further they exposed the child to additional harm by alerting Sandusky, who was the only one who knew the child’s identity, of what McQueary saw in the shower on the night of February 9, 2001.”

 

Our interpretation of the above set the tone from the beginning by opening with this accusatory statement right in the Executive Summary. Yet, as stated in the body of the report to the contrary, the authorities, police, CYS, DPW and the District Attorney’s office at a minimum, were aware of the 1998 allegations, as well as Courtney, the Penn State University Legal Counsel. A full police investigation was done at that time. It was determined by the police, and the district attorney’s office, that no charges would be filed due to lack of sufficient evidence. This is discussed in great detail in the report between pages 43 and 51 as well as what roll each person played in the investigation. It should be noted that Seasock states on pages 44and 45 to Schreffler, “he identified some “gray areas”; he did not find evidence of abuse and had never heard of a 52-year-old-man “becoming a pedophile.” He also stated Sandusky “didn’t fit the profile of a pedophile” and that he couldn’t find any indication of child abuse.”

 

It is our interpretation that this is far bigger and deeper than the authority of the head football coach.

 

The report does indicate on Page 48 that Curley requested an update on the situation that “Coach” wanted to know, under the subject line Joe Paterno.  Curley requested several other updates and referred to coach. Page 49 states “the reference to coach is believed to be Paterno.” Again, speculation on the part of the Freeh Report. it possible in the follow up emails that “coach” wasn’t Paterno? Is it possible that Paterno wanted to know the status so that he could fire Sandusky on the spot once the charges were filed?

 

It is at this point that the report indicates that Paterno, and the rest of the PSU administration, should have parted ways with Sandusky. Apparently the NCAA agrees. It is very easy to say that today, when you know the outcome of this tragedy, however, what basis would the university or Paterno have had for terminating a 29 year employee. The lack of “credible evidence” would’ve likely gotten the university sued.

 

Page 15 & 16 state, “Spanier, Schulttz, Paterno and Curley gave the following reasons for taking no action to identify the February 9, 2001child victim and for not reporting Sandusky to the authorities.”

 

Bullet 2 – Paterno told a reporter, “I didn’t know exactly how to handle it and was afraid to do something that might jeopardize what the university procedure was. So I backed away and turned it over to some other people, people I thought would have a little more expertise than I did. It didn’t work out that way.”

 

Following the bullets on page 16 it states, “taking in to account the available witness statements and evidence the Special Investigative Council finds that it is more reasonable to conclude that, in order to avoid the consequences of bad publicity, the most powerful leaders in the university – Spanier, Schultz, Paterno and Curley – repeatedly concealed facts relating to Sandusky’s child abuse from the authorities, the University’s Board of Trustees, the Penn State Community and the public at large.”

 

Our interpretation – How does the newspaper quote have anything to do with identifying the child? Paterno is a football coach. It is stated several times that he “knew everything.” However, it would be hard to expect him to know how to handle such a situation, as well as “know everything.” The proper thing to do, in any company, is to report any type of major incident up the chain-of-command to the people who are trained to handle this type of situation. That’s what Paterno did.

 

Also, the Freeh Reports comment that “taking into account the available witness statements and evidence the Special Investigative Council finds that it is more reasonable to conclude “this statement indicates that the report has speculated on the findings due to not having interviewed any of the persons directly involved.

 

Obviously the Executive Summary at the beginning of the report sets the tone and Louis Freeh continues throughout to attempt to justify his “speculations” by bringing up the same points several times. He stated on pages 14, 68, and 76 that the men had failed to inquire as to the safety and well being, especially by not attempting to determine the identity of the child in the Lasch building in 2001.

 

Pages 19-31 of the report identify some significant events in the Sandusky timeline. A summary of those events follows:

 

  • ·        May 3, 1998 – Sandusky assaults Victim 6 in the Lasch Building shower.
  • ·        May 4-30, 1998 – Five bullet points are made of the activities during that period. Paterno is not mentioned.
  • ·        June 1998 – Five additional bullet points are made regarding the investigation and Paterno is not mentioned.
  • ·        January 1999 – Sandusky requests to coach one more seasons to earn his 30 years of service.
  • ·        May – August 1999 – Paterno agrees to allow Sandusky to coach “as long as I’m the coach”. Sandusky is also granted “emeritus” status by Spanier after receiving the request from Schultz. This status provides several privileges including access to University Recreational Facilities.
  • ·        December 1999 – Sandusky brings Victim 4 to the 1999 Alamo Bowl and assaults him in the hotel room. Our note, this is Sandusky’s last game as a coach.
  • ·        November 2000 – Sandusky assaults Victim 8 in the Lasch Building shower. Janitors observe assault by Sandusky in the shower but do not report it for fear “they will get rid of all of us.”
  • ·        February 9, 2001 – McQueary observes Sandusky assaulting Victim 2 in the shower of the Lasch Building.
  • ·        February 10-12, 2001 – McQueary reports the incident to Paterno who reports it to Schultz and Curley. Schultz reports to University outside counsel Courtney. A “heads up” meeting is held with Spanier. They agree that Curley will meet with Paterno.
  • ·        February 25-26, 2001 – Spanier, Schultz and Curley meet to develop a plan.
  • ·        February 27 & 28, 2001 – Curley indicated he has changed his mind about the plan “after giving it more thought and talking it over with Joe yesterday.”
  • ·        February 27 & 28, 2001 – Spanier and Schultz accept Curley’s revised plan.
  • ·        March 5, 2001 – Curley meets with Sandusky to tell him the plan. He also tells him he will be notifying the Second Mile.
  • ·        March 19, 2001 – Curley meets with the executive director of the Second Mile and shared the information they had with him. The Second Mile leadership concludes the matter is a “non-incident” and takes no further action.
  • ·        July 24, 2001 – Schultz leads a transaction to sell a parcel of University property to The Second Mile for $168,500.
  • ·        August 2001 – Sandusky assaults Victim 5 in the Lasch Building.
  • ·        Our note – Sandusky is retired and working as the “face” of the Second Mile. He is performing many functions including performing youth summer camps at various University facilities.
  • ·        No further activities until January 7, 2010 when the University received subpoenas from the Pennsylvania Attorney General.

During this lengthy timeline Sandusky requested and was granted a retirement package after being told by Paterno in a letter dated May 28, 1999 that he would not be the next Penn State head coach. (page 57 and 58) As a result of this action, Sandusky submitted a list of “retirement requests” that included annual annuities for 5 years, an on-going relationship between the Second Mile and Penn State, as well as continuing “visibility” at Penn State. Sandusky also wanted “active involvement in developing an outreach program featuring Penn State Athletes and sought “ways for {him} to continue to work with young people through Penn State. It is at this time that Paterno offers Sandusky the opportunity to continue to coach.

On June 13, 1999, Curley emailed Shultz and Spanier and stated that he “touched base with Joe and we are in agreement that we should not do anything more for Jerry.” (page 58).

On June 17, 1999, Wendell Courtney, the University’s then outside legal counsel, provided Curley with a draft “retirement perquisite agreement for Sandusky. Included were the items Sandusky asked for.

On June 21, 1999 a revision was added requesting free use for life of “University weight rooms and fitness facilities available to faculty and staff.”

On June 22, 1999, Sandusky and Curley agreed to revise the permitted use to include “a locker, weight rooms, fitness facilities and training room in the East area locker room complex.” (page 59).

Our interpretation, it appears that Paterno was in agreement of some sort of package for Sandusky up to June 13, 1999 when he stated “we should not do anything more.” After June 13 several modifications were made to the agreement that were defining access to the facilities. Paterno is not mentioned in the report any time after the June 13 note.

Moving forward to Fall 2000. A University janitor witnesses Sandusky assaulting a young boy in the Lasch Building showers. He reports it to another janitor as well as a senior janitor at the time of the incident. They choose not to report the incident to anyone. Janitor “B” reported that the incident “would have been like going against the President of the United States in my eyes.” “I know Paterno has so much power, if he wanted to get rid of someone, I would have been gone.” He explained “football runs this University,” and said “the University would have closed ranks to protect the football program at all costs.” (page 65).

Our interpretation, the last quote doesn’t sound like a quote from a janitor but either way, three adult males chose not to report this incident to anyone in authority. Anything that Paterno “would’ve done” is speculation. In the case of Paterno he can’t be held accountable for this incident when it wasn’t reported and he knew nothing about it.

The timeline moves to February 9, 2001 when the McQueary incident is observed. As is well documented, McQueary reported the incident to Paterno on February 10, 2001. Paterno met with Curley and Schultz on February 11, 2001 and reported what McQueary told him. On February 11, 2001, Schultz reached out to legal counsel, Wendell Courtney, to discuss the “reporting of suspected child abuse.” On February 12, 2001, Curly and Shultz met with Spanier to give him a “heads up.” (pages 67 and 68). The report indicates that McQueary, Paterno, Curley and Schultz are in agreement with what was said from person to person in their meetings, although indications are that McQueary’s first report to Paterno was not graphic in nature. There were many meetings in the next few weeks involving Curley, Schultz and Spanier as plans were being developed on how to address the issues with Sandusky. In an email from Curley dated February 27, 2001 to Schultz and Spanier, Curley states “I had scheduled a meeting with you this afternoon about the subject we discussed on Sunday. After giving it more thought and talking it over with Joe yesterday – I am uncomfortable with what we agreed were the next steps.” (page 74). There are more details of the plan documented in the report. Later on February 27, 2001Spanier agrees to move forward with Curley’s revised plan. The following day, Schultz agrees with Curley and Spanier.

It is at this point in the report, page 75, that Freeh inserts the comments that a Senior Penn State official referred to Curley as Paterno’s “errand boy.” Athletic Department staff said Paterno’s words carried a lot of weight with Curley, who would run big decisions by Paterno.

Curley meets with Sandusky and tells him “about the information that we received, that we were uncomfortable with the information and that I was going to take the information and report it to the executive director of the Second Mile and that I did not want him in the future to be in the athletic facilities with any young people.” (page 76).

As a follow up to the Curley – Sandusky meeting, Curley did meet with the Second Mile executive director who later advised two Second Mile Trustees of the meeting. They concluded the matter was a “non-incident for the Second Mile and there was no need to do anything further.” The executive director did meet with Sandusky on Curley’s concerns regarding bringing kids on campus, and Sandusky responded that it only applied to the locker rooms. The executive director urged him to get the issue clarified. (page 78).

Our interpretation is that when McQueary reported the incident to Paterno he reported it up the line to his supervisors who are far more prepared to handle this type of situation than a football coach. It appears to us that Freeh added the comments about the Curley/Paterno relationship to lead the reader to believe that Curley went to Paterno and Paterno changed the plan. I have run things by my father my whole life, and he’s given me things to think about that at times have caused me to change my mind, but he’s never made a decision for me in my adult life. We don’t see Curley running things by Paterno as being unusual. It’s clear that Paterno was Curleys mentor, we find nothing wrong with that. We also find it interesting that the name of Wendell Courtney keeps popping up. Finally, does the Second Mile have any responsibility in this tragedy? Three more adults know that there’s been a situation and have no interest in stopping it.

Finally, Sandusky’s continued access to the University and football facilities is discussed at great length. (pages 104-106). The Freeh Report states, “Spanier, Schultz, Paterno and Curley were aware of the allegations against Sandusky in 1998 and 2001. Nonetheless, they put children in danger by permitting Sandusky to participate in these activities and by providing continued support of Second Mile activities.” (page 104). There is a great deal written about Sandusky’s continued access to the Lasch Building, the East Area Locker Room Building, offices, the Nittany Lion Club at Beaver Stadium, his Football Camps and his continued business dealings with the University after his retirement. (pages 105 and 106). It is at this point that Freeh states again that, “Despite Spanier’s, Schultz’s, Paterno’s and Curley’s knowledge of criminal investigations of Sandusky regarding child abuse as early as 1998, they failed to control Sandusky’s access to the University’s facilities and campuses.”  These pages of the report do not mention Paternos name anywhere, nor do they mention Spanier or Schultz. The only name mentioned is Curley reversing his decision to remove Sandusky from the football season ticket list in 2011. Sandusky was still considered a significant representative of the University in his retirement, however, there’s no indication of who approved this.

Regarding Sanduskys continued access to the facilities, when asked in 2011by some members of the Athletic Department staff if Sandusky could be restricted from the athletic facilities, Penn State General Counsel Cynthia Baldwin told them that the University could not take the keys. Baldwin advised “that because of Sandusky’s emeritus status and the fact that he had not been charged with a crime, his access could not be eliminated without the University being sued.” (page 106 and 107). As a follow up the report states that Sandusky was asked to return his keys, however, the locks were changed and it is not known if the keys were ever returned.

Our interpretation; if the university legal counsel stated that the key could not be taken away from Sandusky based on his status why does the report call out Paterno and the others for allowing him access? Also, at no point in the timeline between March 2001and 2010 are there any entries regarding any communication between Paterno and Sandusky, or anyone else for that matter. There is a 9 year gap in the report. There’s no way to tell, based on the report, if Sandusky used the facilities every day while everyone was at work, or if he used them after normal work hours, on weekends or when the team was on the road. The report indicates that Sandusky had a free pass to go nearly anywhere he wanted but it doesn’t indicate that he did. It is noted that he had an office that he gave up in between 2007 and 2008 due to overcrowding.

There are several other areas discussed in the report that relate to the Clery Act and the lack of training in this area from the administration to the football staff, as well as an extensive list of recommendations to improve the University moving forward. It is noted that Paterno, Curley and McQueary were obligated by law to report this incident to the University Police Department for inclusion in Clery Act statistics and for determining whether a timely warning should be issued to the University community. (page 118). It is also noted that Paterno, Curley and McQueary did report the incident to Schultz who, as SVP-FB, was ultimately in charge of the University Police Department. However, Schultz was not a law enforcement officer and was not the person designated to receive Clery Crime reports. Arguably, as the senior leaders of the University, Schultz and Spanier should have ensured compliance with the Clery Act regarding the incident. (page 118).

Our interpretation: the failure of any of the individuals to report per the Clery Act appears to be a lack of training on the part of the University to its employees. You can’t report on something you don’t know about.

The final timeline:

November 9, 2011 – Joe Paterno was fired as head football coach at Penn State University after 62 years of service.

January 22, 2012 – Joe Paterno died at the age of 86.

July 22, 2012 – the famous Paterno statue was removed from outside Beaver Stadium based on the findings and presentation of the Freeh Report.

July 23, 2012 – 112 Penn State football victories, 111 credited to Paterno were removed from the record books by the NCAA and Penn State was given the harshest penalties ever by the NCAA based on the finding of the Freeh Report.

 

Our Conclusions:

  • ·        The Freeh Report is highly speculative in nature.
  • ·        The Freeh Report adds comments and emphasis as it sees fit. Examples, the Curley comment in regards to being Paternos “errand boy” and the continued inference that Paterno, Spanier, Schultz and Curley left Victim 2 in danger by not attempting to find out his identity.
  • ·        The Freeh Report leads the reader down a path to believe the story based on speculation like a mystery novel.
  • ·        As a result of the 1998 legal investigation, in which no criminal charges were filed, Joe Paterno, or anyone else in the Penn State administration, can’t be held accountable for any inaction based on the results of the police investigation.
  • ·        It appears that Sandusky’s retirement was not a result of the 1998 incident.
  • ·        It appears that others, besides Paterno, modified the Sandusky retirement plan to include additional facilities.
  • ·        It seems clear that Paterno, nor anyone else but the janitors, can be held accountable for what the janitors witnessed that they chose not to report.
  • ·        It appears that a decision was made to not publicly report the 2001McQueary incident to outside authorities other than the Second Mile. This decision was ultimately approved by Spanier and agreed to by Schultz but the reason is speculated in the report that it was to not bring bad publicity to the University, which is highly speculative. The truth will come out when Schultz and Curley speak under oath.  
  • ·        Penn State University provided a “knee jerk” reaction based on what they interpreted as media and public outcry. As a result, the University did not see or hear the Freeh Report before it was put out publicly in the Louis Freeh press conference. This created a media and public frenzy that led to the demise of the Paterno legacy.
  • ·        Once the report was public, the University again responded irrationally in regards to the Paterno statue. This decision again appears to be a “knee jerk” reaction based on media and public outcry.
  • ·        The NCAA took the opportunity to “pile on” Paterno and Penn State because the University chose not to defend itself even after the report was made public. This decision brings an end to the Paterno legacy.
  • ·        Based on the press conference alone, anyone not having actually read the report is led to believe that the findings are clear in regard to Paterno’s guilt in not reporting child abuse when he had absolute knowledge that it was taking place, that he allowed it to continue by providing access to University facilities and that he, as Head Football Coach, after properly reporting the abuse as was told to him by McQueary, should be held accountable for not having personally continued to pursued charges rather than leave those duties to those better qualified in that area. This has led to the demise of the Paterno legacy.

Feel free to click the COMMENT/RESPONSE button below and leave your thoughts as well as click the FOLLOW button on the bottom right of this page, input your email address, and receive your Philly Pressbox posts directly in your email.

We would like to thank our sponsor for their support. Click the following link to check out all of their Spring health items. http://www.shop.com/ul!60874!spring+health!www.shop.com%2Fbobsullivan-trends.xhtml?credituser=C9407795  Lastly, click on the business card below to see all of their items.

 

Philly Pressbox Weekly Sports Update – 1/22-28

In Misc Philly Sports on January 29, 2012 at 8:40 am

A quick review of Philly Sports for the week of January 22

  •   We lost Joe Paterno – RIP
  •   We lost Andy Musser – RIP
  •   We said goodbye to Brad Lidge. 2008 was a great season. There’s nothing like being perfect.

We said goodbye to Wilson Valdez. No more 19th inning pitching wins.

Phil Knight –Enough said!!

We found greatness in Penn State, Kenny Jackson, Charlie, Pittman, Jimmy Cefalo, Todd Blackledge, Chris Marrone, Michael Robinson, Michael Mauti, Lauren Perrotti, Jeff Bast, Susan Welch, Kurtis Cleckner and Jay Paterno, Sue Paterno and the Paterno family.

The Phils welcome Juan Pierre. Could he be the leadoff hitter we need?

Congrats to Flyers Claude Giroux, Kimmo Timonen and Scott Hartnell for making the NHL All Star team. Especially Hartnell making his 1st appearance in his 11th season.

Claude Giroux goes to the All Star break 2nd in the league in points

The Flyers go to the All Star break in 2nd place in the Atlantic Division 3 points behind the Rangers.

The 76ers finished the week 3-1 and lead the Atlantic Division by 4 games.

Congrats to Shady McCoy, Jason Peters and Jason Babin for making the Pro Bowl in Hawaii. A special shout out to former Eagle David Akers for another trip to Honolulu.

Temple (15-5) whipped St. Joe’s (13-9), 78-60 at the Liacouras Center. I wish those games were still at the Palestra.

Drexel is 17-5 and has won 9 in a row.

Penn is 11-9 and has won 3 in a row.

LaSalle is 16-6 and has won 3 in a row.

Villanova lost to Marquette falling to 11-12.

The Word of the Day – RESPECT – Spurrier

In Joe Paterno, The Word of the Day on January 27, 2012 at 6:09 am

 

“I have the utmost respect and admiration for Joe Paterno. I’ve coached around 300 college games and only once when I’ve met the other coach at midfield prior to the game have I asked a photographer to take a picture of me with the other coach. That happened in the Citrus Bowl after the ’97 season when we were playing Penn State. I had one of our university photographers take the picture with me and Coach Paterno, and I still have that photo in the den at my house. That’s the admiration I have for Joe Paterno”

Nike CEO Phil Knight at Coach Paterno’s Funeral – Don’t Miss It

In Joe Paterno on January 26, 2012 at 8:02 pm

For those of you that did not see Nike CEO Phil Knights speech at Coach Paterno’s funeral today you must see this. I know who Phil Knight is and what he does and that he has a bunch of money that supports the University of Oregon athletic program. What I didn’t know was that Phil Knight had the same hero that a lot of us have had. This is great, Enjoy!!

WE ARE PENN STATE!!!!

 

 

The Real Joe Paterno by Rick Reilly

In Joe Paterno on January 26, 2012 at 1:11 pm

Paterno & Taliaferro Joe Hermitt/The Patriot-NewsAdam Taliaferro and Joe Paterno in 2010, 10 years after the player and coach had formed a strong bond in the wake of Taliaferro’s horrifying spinal cord injury.
THIS ARTICLE WAS WRITTEN BY RICK REILLY AND APPEARED ON ESPN.COM. It’s another great JoePa article that I wanted to share. Also, the photo above was provided by Joe Hermitt of The Patriot News. I’m only sharing and had nothing to do with writing the article.
 
 

 Maybe you will never be convinced Joe Paterno was a good man who made one catastrophic mistake, but do you have time for just one story? In 2000, Penn State freshman defensive back Adam Taliaferro had his spine crushed when tackling an Ohio State player. He lay on that September field paralyzed and panicked. The first person he saw when he opened his eyes was Paterno, who died Sunday at 85. “He could see I was losing it, but his eyes stayed totally calm,” Taliaferro remembers. “And I remember that familiar, high-pitched voice, going, ‘You’re gonna get through this, Kid. You’re gonna be OK.’ And I just trusted him. I believed it.” Taliaferro wound up in a hospital bed in Philadelphia, everything frozen solid below the neck. Doctors said he had about a 3 percent chance of walking again. And every other week, Paterno would fly to Philly to see him. “He’d bring our trainer and a couple of my teammates,” Taliaferro says. “Nobody in the hospital knew he was there.” Paterno would tell him all the dumb things his teammates and coaches had done lately. Pretty soon, Taliaferro would be laughing his IVs out. “I can’t tell you what that meant to me,” says Taliaferro, now 30. “I’m stuck in that hospital, and here’s Coach Paterno bringing a piece of the team to me, in the middle of the season. How many coaches would do that?” 

One midnight, Taliaferro moved a toe and the first person his dad called was Paterno. His dad held the phone to Adam’s ear and Paterno said, “You’re gonna prove ’em all wrong, Kid!”  From then on, every visit, Paterno wanted to see Taliaferro move something new. “I got to where I wanted to be ready. A finger, a hand, whatever. I wanted to perform for Coach Paterno.” One day, five months into it, Paterno walked in and said, “What’s new, Kid?” Taliaferro swung his legs over the bed, stood and extended his hand to shake. “I’ll never forget his eyes,” he says. “They were already huge behind those Coke-bottle glasses, but they got even bigger.” Paterno gave him a 10-second hug and then said, “Kid, ya make me proud.” 

A man is more than his failings.

 I learned a lot about Paterno when I wrote a story about him in 1986 for Sports Illustrated. I’ve learned a lot about him since. He was a humble, funny and giving man who was unlike any other coach I ever met in college football. He rolled up his pants to save on dry cleaning bills. He lived in the same simple ranch house for the last 45 years. Same glasses, same wife, same job, for most of his adult life. He was a man who had two national championships, five undefeated seasons, and yet for years he drove a white Ford Tempo. In 46 years as a head coach, he never had a single major NCAA violation. He was the only coach I’ve ever known who went to the board of trustees to demand they increase entrance requirements, who went to faculty club meetings to hear the lectures, who listened to opera while drawing up game plans. He was a Depression kid who wouldn’t allow stars on helmets or names on jerseys. And he hated expensive tennis shoes. He’d see a player wearing Air Jordans and say, “It’s not the sneakers, Kid, it’s the person in them.” One day Taliaferro wore an entirely different pair into his office, a pair of “Air Paternos” he’d made himself. “He freaked out,” Taliaferro remembers. “He was about to call Nike. He thought they were real!”

Paterno Nikes

Courtesy of Adam Taliaferro
 
As a gag, Taliaferro made these sneakers to show Paterno. They represented everything the coach did not stand for.

If a player was struggling with a subject, Paterno would make him come to his house for wife Sue’s homemade pasta and her tutoring. One time, he told a high school blue chipper named Bob White he wouldn’t recruit him unless he agreed to read 12 novels and turn in two-page book reports to Sue. They were the first books he ever finished. White wound up with two degrees and a job at the university.Paterno was other things, too, like controlling and immovable. He lingered as head coach when he promised time and again he wouldn’t. And when he needed to follow up on what he’d been told about Jerry Sandusky and a child in the shower in 2002, he failed miserably.

 But he followed up for thousands of others.

 Even though Taliaferro would never play football again, Paterno stayed on him to keep moving. “I came to Penn State to become a lawyer,” he told him. “But I never made it. You could, Kid. You’re smart.” He got the fully recovered Taliaferro a summer internship with the NFLPA in New York and, before you knew it, Taliaferro was a corporate lawyer in Cherry Hill, N.J. He successfully ran for local office there and is now running for the Penn State board of trustees, where he wants to help his school heal from a scandal Paterno made worse with his neglect.

 “The last three months, I’ve just wanted to go up on a rooftop and shout, ‘I wish you knew him like I do!'” Taliaferro says. “I know, in my heart, if he’d understood how serious this situation was, he’d have done more.”  I believe that, too. But if you don’t, I respect that. I only ask this: If we’re so able to vividly remember the worst a man did, can’t we also remember the best?


Follow Rick on Twitter @ReillyRick

Joe Paterno – The Final Football Chapter

In Joe Paterno on January 25, 2012 at 4:45 pm

There have been so many great things written about Joe Paterno this week following his passing and very few of them talked about the football coach. That in itself is truly amazing when you’re talking about the winningest coach in FBS history. This is a lengthy list but one I think that’s worth reading. His accomplishments over 61 years in Happy Valley will never be surpassed.

  • Donated more than $4 million to Penn State, and funded the school’s library.
  • College Football Hall of Fame – 2007
  • Most Wins – 409
  • Most Bowl Wins – 24
  • National Championships – 2, 1982, 1986
  • Undefeated Season – 5, 1968, 1969, 1973, 1986, 1994
  • Big 10 Championships – 3, 1994, 2005, 2008
  • Sports Illustrated Sportsman of the Year – 1986
  • AFCA Coach of the Year – 5, 1968, 1978, 1982, 1986, 2005
  • Walter Camp Coach of the Year – 3, 1972, 1994, 2005
  • Big 10 Coach of the Year – 3, 1994, 2005, 2008
  • George Munger Award – – 3, 1990, 1994, 2005
  • Eddie Robinson Coach of the Year – 3, 1978, 1982, 1986
  • Paul “Bear” Bryant Award – 1, 1986
  • Amos Alonzo Stagg Award – 1, 2002
  • The Home Depot Coach of the Year Award – 1, 2005
  • Sporting News Coach of the Year Award – 1, 2005
  • Most seasons as Head Coach at one university – 44
  • Years on the Penn State staff – 62
  • Beaver Stadium capacity in 1966 – 46,284
  • Beaver Stadium capacity in 2012 – 106,572
  • Winning Seasons – 38, one more than Bear Bryant.
  • 1st Team All Americans – 79.
  • National Football Foundation Scholar-Athletes – 16
  • First-team Capital One/CoSIDA All-Americans – 37
  • NCAA Postgraduate Scholarship winners – 18
  • 1st Team Academic All-American – 13 since 2006.
  • NFL Players – 350+
  • NFL 1st Round Draft Choices – 32
  • U.S, Presidents during his PSU career – 13 starting with Harry Truman
  • Since he became head coach in 1966, there have been 886 coaching changes at FBS schools.
  • Head Coaching Record – 409-136-3
  • Bowl Record – 24-12-1
  • The only coach to win each of the four major bowls—Rose, Orange, Fiesta, and Sugar—as well as the Cotton Bowl Classic, at least once.
  • Penn State won at least three bowl games each decade since 1970.
  • Fiesta Bowl Wins – 6, 1977, 1980, 1981, 1986, 1991, and 1996
  • Orange Bowl Wins –  4, 1968, 1969, 1973, and 2005
  • Outback Bowl Wins – 3, 1995, 1998, 2006
  • Cotton Bowl Wins – 2, 1972 and 1974
  • Citrus Bowl Wins – 2, 1993 and 2010
  • Alamo Bowl Wins – 2, 1999 and 2007
  • Rose Bowl Wins – 1, 1994
  • Sugar Bowl Wins – 1, 1982
  • Liberty Bowl Wins – 1, 1979
  • Aloha Bowl Wins – 1, 1983
  • Holiday bowl Wins – 1, 1989

THE PATERNO TIME LINE TO 704 GAMES – 409 WINS

ASSISTANT COACH

  • May 27, 1950 – Hired by Rip Engle to coach the quarterbacks.
  • September 30, 1950 – 1st game – Penn State defeated Georgetown, 34-14, before a crowd of 16,617 at New Beaver Field.
  • October 29, 1960 – Game #100 Penn State 34 West Virginia 13.

HEAD COACH

  • September 17, 1966 – Win #1. In front of a crowd of 40,911 inside Beaver Stadium a 15-7 win over Maryland. 
  • January 1, 1969: Penn State 15, Kansas 14; first perfect season, 11-0
  • September 26, 1970 – Game #200 Penn State lost to Colorado 41-23, snapping the Nittany Lions’ 31-game unbeaten streak.
  • January 1, 1970: Penn State 10, Missouri 3; second perfect season, 11-0
  • January 1, 1974: Penn State 16, LSU 9; third perfect season, 12-0
  • November. 6, 1976: WIN #100, Penn State 41, N.C. State 20
  • October 21, 1978 – Game #300. Penn State 45-15 Syracuse 15.
  • January 1, 1983 – Penn State won its first National Championship defeating No. 1 Georgia in the Sugar Bowl. 
  • November 22, 1986 – Game #400 Penn State 34 Pittsburgh 14.
  • January 2, 1987 – The Nittany Lions claimed their second National Championship with a 14-10 upset of then No. 1 Miami in the Fiesta Bowl.
  • September. 5, 1987: WIN #200 – Penn State 45, Bowling Green 19
  • January. 2, 1995: Penn State 38, Oregon 20; fifth perfect season, 12-0
  • September 23, 1995 – Game #500 Penn State defeated Rutgers in Giants Stadium, 59-34.
  • September. 12, 1998: WIN #300 – Penn State 48, Bowling Green 3
  • October 27, 2001 – WIN #324. In one of the greatest Penn State comebacks in Beaver Stadium history, the Nittany Lions rallied from a 27-9 deficit to defeat rival Ohio State  The win moved Coach Paterno past Alabama’s Paul “Bear” Bryant into the all-time victories lead in Division I college football history.
  • September 27, 2003 – Game #600 Penn State was upset 20-14 by Minnesota.
  • November 6, 2010 – WIN #400 at Beaver Stadium. Wins 100, 200, 300, 324 and 400 and 409 were all played at Beaver Stadium.  The game was the biggest comeback in Beaver Stadium history under Joe.  Penn State scored 35 unanswered points to overcome a 21-0 deficit to beat Northwestern 35-21. 
  • October 1, 2011 – Game #700 Penn State beat Indiana 16-10 in Bloomington.
  • October 29, 2011 – Win #409 Penn State beat Illinois 10-7 at Beaver Stadium. This would be the final game and final win for Coach Paterno. This was also Game #704.

LaVar Steps Up for JoePa!!

In Joe Paterno on January 24, 2012 at 10:10 am

Following is an interview done with LaVar Arrington yesterday that I wanted to share. Thanks to my friend Don for sharing it with me. I don’t know where it came from so can’t provide a credit. This says it all about Joe Paterno and the lessons taught to so many, even an emotional person like LaVar Arrington. Great job Joe and great job LaVar.

People have been asking about my feelings on this weekend’s passing of Joe Paterno. My phone has not stopped ringing with requests for interviews about Joe.  I know this will be a very long week for me. In a blog entry I posted after his last interview, I pretty much said my piece about my relationship with him and my thoughts on how he handled the scandal. I really thought I would wake up angry and upset today, ready to fight against what I feel took Coach down that final road of no return, but I didn’t. Instead of gearing up to lash out and let my emotions get the best of me for the second time, I actually woke up feeling a great deal of peace. I began recounting so many times I heard that loud distinctive voice directing and teaching. I started envisioning all the funny little moments, like when I use to smack Joe on the behind at team meetings and say, “Good day to be a Nittany Lion coach!”

 I remember the pregame speeches. Boy could he deliver a pregame speech. There are so many moments yesterday evening and this morning that I’m recounting about my time at school with him. I remember one time he sent for me to come to his office. At the time that was a scary invite, and I was right; my grades had started to slip after I became a “superstar” and he got into me pretty good about it.

The reason why I feel peace about Joe’s passing, is because all that Joe was is what I represent today and will pass on to my children. People may try and tear down his legacy. They will attempt to turn Joe into something he was not because of the Jerry Sandusky scandal. I waged war on the Penn State board of trustees because in my opinion they allowed this to happen. 

My focus was misguided. I should’ve approached the coaching search the way Joe would have — with grace and thoughtfulness. I made a terrible mistake when I said I was done with Penn State. I let frustration and anger guide my actions. But today my focus is not about attacking those who wish to say or do things to try and tarnish his legacy or ours. It’s not even about defending him in the media every day. Joe’s work speaks for itself. Through it all, he maintained the man that he was and even when he had one last chance to open fire on those who sacrificed him, he didn’t. I realize it’s our actions, in how we live our lives and impact others, that will forever tell the true story of Joseph Vincent Paterno.

Today I’m rededicating myself to strive to work harder, to be better — a better husband, a better dad, a better son, a better role model. Today I will carry the lessons taught to me by the great people who have graced my life and work to be better.

 The biggest tribute I can give to Coach Paterno is taking all that I’ve learned from him and apply it in my life. I, too, someday will cease to exist on this earth physically, but to know that my good works impacted someone so much that they would speak of me the way I speak of my former coach today, that’s the best way for me to honor the man who for three years taught me in his own way what it took to be a man.

 Thank you so much for being a great example, Joe. I will keep your memory alive as I too am not a perfect man, but yet and still a man. That means I can admit when I’ve made a mistake. I will protect and provide for my family, I will never yield standing on my spiritual, moral values and principles. Most important, I will always keep God first in the things that I do in my life.

 I didn’t see Joe much after I left school, so selfishly a small part of me will continue on as if he is still around just enjoying retirement. I hope in some way, maybe he is.

 Take care, Joe.

Sincerely,

LaVar Arrington, Class of ’99. We are Penn State.

The Word of the Day – Confidence – Paterno

In Joe Paterno, The Word of the Day on January 24, 2012 at 7:46 am

CONFIDENCE

“Besides pride, loyalty, discipline, heart and mind, confidence is the key to all of the locks”

 

Joe Paterno

%d bloggers like this: